A member of the Avery/Watauga Assoc of Realtors sent this information:
Declaration of Restrictions recorded against every residential lot developed by Carolina Caribbean Corporation require the following:
Paragraph 10: No commercial signs, including "for rent", "for sale", and other similar signs, shall be erected or maintained on any lot except with the written permission of the Company or except as may be, requires by legal proceedings, it being understood that the Company will not grant permission for said sign unless their erection is reasonably necessary to avert serious hardship to the property owner. Property identification and like signs exceeding a combined total of more than three (3) square feet may not be erected without the written permission of the Company.
Below paragraph 19, the restrictions go on to say:
In the event of a violation or breach of any of these restrictions by any property owner, or agent, or agent of such owner, the owners of lots in the neighborhood or subdivision, or any of them jointly or severally, shall have the right to proceed at law or in equity to compel a compliance to the terms hereof or to prevent the violation or breach in any event. In addition to the foregoing, the Company shall have the right, whenever there shall have been built on any lot in the subdivision any structure which is in violation if these restrictions, to enter upon the property where such violation exists, and summarily abate or remove the same at the expense of the owner, if after thirty (30) days within the abatement or removal shall not be deemed a trespass. The failure to enforce any right, reservation, restriction, or condition contained in this Declaration of Restrictions, however long continued shall not be deemed a waiver of the rights to do so hereafter; as to the dame breach or as to a breach occurring prior or subsequent thereto and shall not bar or affect its enforcement. The invalidation by any court of any restrictions in this Declaration of Restrictions contained shall in no way affect any of the other restrictions, but they shall remain in full force and effect.
Obviously any property owner can file a suit against any sign violation. But as a "REALTOR" I am compelled by our code of ethics to recommend an easier way to deal with the problem. Most agents in our community are members of the Avery/Watauga Association of Realtors and subscribe to their Code of Ethics. A member of the public can file a grievance against a Realtor for violating our restrictive covenants.
The associations address is: Avery/Watauga Association of Realtors
P.O. Box 607
Boone, NC 28607 (828) 262-5437
fax (828) 262-1530
awaronline.org Laurie Phillips, executive director
Nancy
WELCOME TO THE HIGHEST CLUB EAST OF THE ROCKIES!
August 31, 2007
Labels
- Artists (6)
- Beech Mountain (17)
- Beech Mountain Club (19)
- Birds animals (2)
- BMC History Excerpts (8)
- Bridge (8)
- Church (4)
- Club Trips (4)
- deer (8)
- dogs (1)
- fall (2)
- Flowers (3)
- friends (1)
- Gardem C;ib (1)
- golf course (3)
- Golf Meeting (3)
- Golf18 (60)
- Golf9 (30)
- GolfMen (10)
- Ground and Greens (3)
- hail storm (1)
- halloween (2)
- herb (12)
- Hikes (17)
- Hummingbird (7)
- Medical (2)
- new baby Parent (1)
- snow (5)
- Swimming (3)
- Tennis (33)
- theatre (1)
- Wine Society (3)
- winter (7)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2007
(187)
-
▼
August
(44)
- HOW TO COMPLAIN ABOUT REAL ESTATE SIGNS
- Barbara More is sharing her secret!
- GOLF PRACTICE FACILITY IS NOW OPEN!
- BMLGA HAD PLAY, LUNCHEON, AND ELECTION OF OFFICERS
- Two Thoughts from Nancy
- FOUND DOG
- Do You Want to See Real Estates Signs all over Bee...
- Memorial Service for Harrison "Harry" Gagne
- Pictures of the New Golf Practice Facility!
- WHERE ARE BILL AND ERMA JAMES?
- Garden & Herb Society Annual Herbal Tea
- The Beech Mountain Garden and Herb Society, con't.
- Be Careful on the Beech Mtn Parkway!
- Here Are the Actual Team Scores for the BMC M/G
- BMC Member Guest
- HAVE YOU SEEN A HURT DEER?
- BEECH MOUNTAIN CLUB MEMBER-GUEST
- Another Low-Impact Hike picture
- Lo-Impact Hikers On the Go!!
- Special News about Max Richards
- No title
- BMLGA had two wonderful days of their Championship.
- BMLGA Championship Pictures
- Beech Mountain Ladies Golf Association Winners
- Here are Members Receiving their Prizes
- BMLGA Championship Winners!
- BMLGA begins Championship Tournament
- More Information on Harry Gagne
- Lady Niners Crystal Cup 7/26/2007
- Lady Niners Member Guest 8/9/07
- Hit the Beach on Beech Mountain
- Hit the Beach, con't
- Hit the Beach, con't
- Hit the beach, con't.
- Hit the Beach, con't.
- HARRY GAGNE PASSED AWAY THIS WEEK
- More info about Adobe Elements & Corel Painter Two...
- SPECIAL DIGITAL PHOTO CLASSES!
- SUSIE O'CONNELL WINS AWARD!
- Vote for Jim and Beech
- BMLGA Pictures
- More Pictures from the BMLGA Member-Guest
- BMC Low Impact Hikers Canoe the New River
- BMC Low Impact Hikers (con't)
-
▼
August
(44)
3 comments:
Three or four weeks ago I had the opportunity to stop by the Town of Beech Mountain and meet with Bobby Dziewulski who works in the Inspections/Zoning Dept. Bobby is a very nice person who never hesitates to take the time to explain the various ordinances that I may have questions on. The ordinances are available for viewing on the Town's website: http://www.townofbeechmountain.com/services/ordinances.html. However, the language of some of these ordinances is vague so I always go to the Town for clarification if I am not sure of the intent of the language. At the time of my meeting with Bobby, I asked about the real estate agency signs that are cropping up way too much lately and showed him Page XIX-16 of TITLE V, Ch. 51 of the Zoning Ordinances. This page contains language Section 1917. Real Estate Signs. Bobby told me that the language was put in to give owners guidelines as to how they can advertise their property; real estate agent signs are not allowed. I replied that I had heard that interpretation for as long as I have been coming to Beech Mountain and certainly agreed with it but that the language did not seem to clearly reflect it. Additionally, it appears that others do not understand it either as there are more and more real estate signs cropping up on residential properties. He said other agents had expressed the same concern and that if I would give him the street addresses where the signs were located he would make sure they were taken care of.
On August 21st, I was provided with a copy of an undated letter that was prepared by Bobby and addressed to Beech Mountain Real Estate Agents. The content, verbatim, is as follows:
"As many of you know, the original declaration of restrictions of the Beech Mountain Subdivision made by Carolina Caribbean prohibited most real estate signage. Although the declaration of restrictions prohibited such signage the document provided the authority to enforce the restriction to Carolina Caribbean Corporation. Therefore Town officials do not have the authority to enforce the restriction.
The Town Code of Ordinances allows for real estate signs if they meet the following criteria:
· The property owner must obtain the sign
· The sign must not exceed two square feet
· The sign must be erected on the property that is being offered for sale
· The sign shall conform to all other applicable provisions of the sign ordinance
· The sign shall be removed within seven days after the property is sold
· All real estate sign permits are valid for a period of six months
Sign permits will be available at the Town Hall. If you have any further questions contact Keith or Bobby at 387-4236
Bobby Dziewulski"
In researching this new information, I was told that this issue has come up in years past through the Town Council and that attorneys over the years have agreed that the Town cannot, or will not, enforce the deed restrictions but that individual property owners who fall under those restrictions CAN enforce them on others through the courts if they are so inclined. It is my understanding that this is the ONLY WAY our deed restrictions can be enforced. Accordingly, REAL ESTATE AGENTS CURRENTLY DO HAVE THE ABILITY TO PLACE "FOR SALE" SIGNS on residential as well as commercial properties on Beech Mountain without retribution as long as they follow the current zoning ordinances relating to signs.
With 475 residential homes, condominium units and vacant lots currently listed on the MLS system for Beech Mountain, this allowance of real estate signs by real estate agents has the potential of allowing our beautiful mountain to have the appearance of having a 'fire sale'.
I am a real estate broker and REALTOR, as well as a homeowner and landowner on Beech Mountain. I understand the duties and obligations of doing everything I legally can as a real estate broker and REALTOR for my clients, many of whom are also Beech Mountain property owners. I do not take these obligations and duties lightly. Now that the non-enforceability of the deed restrictions has been addressed and put into writing, I will explain to my clients who wish to list their property for sale that if we put a sign on every property that is currently for sale it is not going to be a pretty sight and may actually detract from it's value. I truly believe this, have spoken with others to get their opinion and have found, without exception, it is theirs as well. As a real estate broker, I just don't think posting a real estate office sign as advertising is in the best interest of anyone except for the particular real estate office advertising the property; I have a duty to my client, not my office or myself.
There are so many other ways to advertise property rather than potentially demean the value of Beech Mountain itself by erecting a mass quantity of signs... and I'm sure it will be a mass quantity if it isn't stopped now before all real estate offices jump on the bandwagon. A prospective buyer has only to stop into any real estate office on this mountain or off, or pick up a Homes and Land or Real Estate Book magazine, to find out what properties are for sale in their criteria and budget. And if an owner still wants a sign in their yard or on their house advertising the sale they can always simply include their phone number on their own Town approved sign and refer anyone calling to the listing agent. However, if a client of mine decides he/she wants a real estate office sign on his/her property, it will then become my obligation to do so.
As a Beech Mountain property owner myself, I do not want to see our mountain become an eyesore due to the potential of how many signs could actually be put up in addition to the existing "for sale by owner", commercial and builder signs. I am also concerned that if the Town cannot enforce this particular deed restriction, do we have zoning ordinances and/or other safeguards in place to protect all of our other deed restrictions? I do not know why the authority to enforce these restrictions was not transferred to another entity at the time Carolina Caribbean left the picture or if there is some way the authority can be established at this time. If you are as concerned about this issue as I am, you may want to contact your attorney to see what you, as an individual, can do to protect your rights.
Debbie E. Canady
Well said Debbie but with all due respect there is a mistake in your blog. A sign with the owners phone number but is actually a listed property to be referred to the broker is considered a "Blind Ad" by the NC Real Estate Commission and is illegal under NC real estate license law. I have removed such signs by my sellers in the past which were put up without my knowledge. My firm probably has more house/condo listings than any firm on Beech and believe me, we have no intention of participating in "sign wars". We do have directional signs for our open houses but they are up only for about 3 hours. I do not want to allow an individual client to force me to violate the "for sale, for rent" sign deed restrictions. I have been here for over 20 years and believe the deed restrictions are still enforceable even without town involvement. This has come up before, there is nothing new under the sun. Let's also address the signs all over Beech that violate the town ordinance and have nothing to do with real estate sales.
Tom Fehl, Owner/Broker
Buchanan Real Estate
Sheesh. Talk about a tempest in a teacup. But that's typical of Beech. I see nothing offensive about a 2 x 2 wooden sign, and think that the 10% or so of properties for sale on the mountain hardly bespeak that the mountain is in extremis, in view of the glut elsewhere.
Teri Fehl
Post a Comment